Monday, December 13, 2010

Book Club Socratic Seminar

During your Book Club Discussions be sure to answer the following questions.  To do this you MUST:

1. Highlight the questions, then copy them (right click & copy, or edit & copy).
2. Open a word document.
3. Paste the questions into the word document.
4. Type your answers into the word document.
5. Spell check your word document.
6. Put the names of ALL GROUP MEMBERS (first and last) and your GROUP (J, K, L, M)
6. Highlight your entire word document, then copy it (right click & copy, or edit & copy).
7. Come back to this blog, paste your word document into the comment section of this blog and submit comment.
8.  IF you can not submit your answers as a comment, e-mail them to tballestyuim@gmail.com.  The subject heading should read BCSS Group ___ Last Name, First Name (of ONE person in your group).  The answers should be ATTACHED as a word document, NOT in the BODY of the E-MAIL.

Group:                   BC Book Title:
                BC Book Author:

Book Club Socratic Seminar Log

Directions:  Complete this log for each Book Club Socratic Seminar you have (small group discussion about BC Book / Monster).

1.      Question(s) we discussed today (from back of book mark or your own THOUGHT PROVOKING question—remember, NO “YES” or “NO” answer questions):




2.      Page numbers we went back to when discussing our responses to the question(s) (list any page numbers that came up during your discussion):




3.      One thing we learned from our discussion today (something important, for example: a new understanding of your main character, a connection to one of our other books, a new understanding about identity, or any other important idea or thought your group discusses).



4.      One thing we will discuss the next time we meet (a question we want to answer, an idea we want to develop, a character we want to pay attention to).



5.      The passage from the book that we discussed today that we think is most important.



6.      Why we think this is the most important passage we discussed today.




Identity Questions to Start BC Socratic Seminar

This list of questions can also be found on the back of your bookmark for the book club book.
If you do not know what to discuss, or your discussion ends before time is up, use one of these questions.

Questions to help focus your discussion: (use these if you are not sure where to start your conversation):

~ How did the author deal with the idea of IDENTITY in the reading since you last met?

~ What does the author seem to be implying (hinting at) about identity?

~ What message does the author seem to be giving the reader about identity?
      EX.  Who controls a person’s identity?        
Is identity defined by others?  

Do individuals define their own identity?

What defines identity?  Actions?  Thoughts?  Words?  Beliefs?  Friends?  Family? 
Appearance?  Abilities?  Inabilities?  Community?  Family?  Choices?  How others see us? 
How we see ourselves?

~ Can people change their identities?
~ Is identity fixed (unchangeable) or fluid (changing and shifting like a liquid sloshing in a bottle)?
 ~ If identity is fluid (changing and shifting like a liquid sloshing in a bottle), how does it change?  Is
   change permanent or can a person have multiple identities (more than one)?
 ~ If people can have more than one identity, how does that work? 
 ~ What makes identity change?  Is the change by choice or because of a situation?  Who has control
    over this?            

~ Which character(s) are dealing with identity?
~ Are any characters struggling with what they think of themselves?

~ Are any characters struggling with what others think of them?

~ Are issues of identity moving the PLOT forward (helping the story to develop)?  If they are, how is
    this happening?

~ Do any of the characters or situations in your BC book connect to Monster or FWD?  If so HOW?